Gen 2+ vs Gen 3 Night Vision: A Blind Side by Side Test (Credit: 4MR Ranch)

Illustration: a forest logging road on a dark night with no moon and a deer about 50 m out, seen side by side through a Gen 2+ tube (left) and a Gen 3 tube (right). The deer is easier to see on the Gen 3.ILLUSTRATION
Dark, no moon: the Gen 3 pulls clearly ahead; the deer at 50 m is easier to see. Illustration made by Night Operators from the measured 4MR Ranch blind test, not footage from it. Watch the full 4MR Ranch blind test video.

Quick answer: In a blind test by 4MR Ranch, a 1619 FOM Gen 2+ tube and a 2059 FOM Gen 3 tube in identical housings were so close that the tester could barely tell them apart under moonlight. The Gen 3 tube pulled ahead in the darkest scenes, but for most nights a high grade Gen 2+ tube gets you most of the way for a fraction of the Gen 3 price.

Most people who write off night vision do it because they assume the only "good" option is Gen 3 at five figures. Kyle from 4MR Ranch set out to test that assumption properly. He put two tubes, one Gen 2+ and one Gen 3, into two identical binocular housings, filmed both with the same camera settings, and did not know which was which until after the video went live. Here is the full test, and what we take away from it.

Video: Gen 2 vs Gen 3 Night Vision; Can You Tell The Difference? (Blind Test) by 4MR Ranch, published 11 April 2026. All footage and testing are theirs.

These are not our units. The two binoculars in this test belong to the tester, not to Night Operators, and both were fitted with upgraded optics. What you see in the video shows those two test units, not our products. We use the test for what it says about Gen 2+ and Gen 3 tubes.

How was the blind test set up?

The only thing that changed between the two units was the tube. Both units used the same binocular housing and the same optics, and Kyle kept the camera settings the same for every clip so the footage compares like for like (6:06). He referred to each unit only by its housing serial number, 0438 and 0393, and asked the maker not to tell him which held which tube until the video was public (1:44).

The answer, from 4MR Ranch's pinned comment on the video:

Housing Tube SNR Resolution FOM
0438 Gen 2+ 25.3 64 lp/mm 1619
0393 Elbit Gen 3 28.6 72 lp/mm 2059

In the video Kyle calls the Gen 3 tube an L3. His pinned comment corrects that: it is an Elbit tube. Before the reveal he also described both units as roughly 1800 FOM; the measured numbers above are the ones that count.

What do FOM, SNR and resolution actually mean?

FOM (figure of merit) is the single number most people shop by, and it is simple math: resolution multiplied by signal to noise ratio. Our full explainer is in what FOM means for night vision, but here is the short version.

  • Resolution (lp/mm) is how much fine detail the tube can separate: line pairs per millimetre. Higher means crisper edges on branches, wires and text.
  • SNR (signal to noise ratio) is how clean the image stays when there is very little light. Higher SNR means less "snow" or scintillation in dark scenes.
  • FOM = SNR x resolution.

For the two tubes in the test:

  • Gen 2+ (0438): 25.3 x 64 = 1619 FOM
  • Gen 3 (0393): 28.6 x 72 = 2059 FOM

On paper that is about 27 percent more FOM for the Gen 3 tube, made of about 13 percent more SNR and about 12.5 percent more resolution. That sounds like a big gap. The interesting part of this video is how small it looked in the field.

What did the tester see under a full moon?

The first scene was a field and tree line under a full moon with city glow, about the best conditions night vision ever gets (6:17). Through the Gen 2+ unit (0438), Kyle picked out deer bedded down at about 85 yards, a power line pole at about 100 yards, the cable strung between the poles against the trees, and a bare embankment and power line tower at about 200 yards. His words for the image: pretty crisp, with the moon's shadows visible on the trees.

Switching to the Gen 3 unit (0393), he felt the power line cable was slightly less distinct and the image had more of a teal hue (8:45). He also pointed out the halo around a bright light on the left of the frame as one of the few visible differences.

His verdict for this scene went to the Gen 2+ tube, based on how clearly he could still see that power line cable (9:59). He was quick to add that he would be happy with either unit, and that this was close to ideal light.

That result is worth a second look. On paper the Gen 3 tube has the higher resolution (72 against 64 lp/mm), yet the tester's eye preferred the Gen 2+ image in good light. That is one person on one night through a camera, so we would not read too much into it either way. What it does show is that a single spec line does not decide what you see.

Illustration: a desert canyon trail under a full moon, seen side by side through a Gen 2+ tube (left) and a Gen 3 tube (right). The two pictures look nearly the same; the Gen 3 is a little brighter.ILLUSTRATION
Illustration, close up, side by side: the canyon rock face and a far ledge magnified 3 times, Gen 2+ on the left and Gen 3 on the right. Nearly identical; the Gen 2+ edges a hair crisper.ILLUSTRATION
Full moon: nearly impossible to tell apart; the tester gave the Gen 2+ the edge on fine detail. Under it, the same spots magnified. Illustration made by Night Operators from the measured 4MR Ranch blind test, not footage from it. Watch the full 4MR Ranch blind test video.

What happened at 50 to 500 yards?

Next Kyle set up black boards at 50, 100, 200, 300, 400 and 500 yards on an open field (10:18).

  • Gen 2+ (0438), gain set to a usable noise level: the 500 yard board was visible without too much difficulty, and the wood edges of the 100 yard backstop were clear. With the built in IR illuminator on, the image became very clean, so much so that he turned the gain down (11:24).
  • Both units at full gain, no extra light: this is where the Gen 3 tube showed its advantage. Kyle saw more of the bushes and more ambient light behind the tree branches through 0393, and felt he could see the 500 yard board a little better than through 0438 (12:42). Branch detail looked about the same on both.

His summary of this round: even side by side he could hardly tell them apart beyond subtle features, though the Gen 3 unit made the 50 yard board pop more clearly to his eye in low light (13:57).

What happened in a nearly dark room?

The last tests were indoors with almost no light: a sheet of paper with rows of shrinking text in a guest room with the blinds closed, then the same sheet in a dark closet at twice the magnification (15:11).

  • Gen 3 (0393) read down to about row six of the chart and showed good detail in the room.
  • Gen 2+ (0438) reached about row four or five, with more noise and a little less detail when panning the room.

This is the clearest Gen 3 win in the video, and it lines up with the numbers: higher SNR means a cleaner image when there is almost nothing to amplify. Kyle's guess at this point, correctly, was that 0393 held the Gen 3 tube.

Illustration: the inside of a very dark barn with tools on the wall and a sign at the far end, seen side by side through a Gen 2+ tube (left) and a Gen 3 tube (right). The Gen 3 picture is cleaner and the sign is readable.ILLUSTRATION
Illustration, close up, side by side: the far wall sign magnified 4 times and the tools on the wall 3 times, Gen 2+ on the left and Gen 3 on the right. The sign reads TACK ROOM on the Gen 3 and cannot be read on the Gen 2+.ILLUSTRATION
Very dark: the Gen 3 wins, with a cleaner picture and a readable sign. Under it, the same spots magnified. Illustration made by Night Operators from the measured 4MR Ranch blind test, not footage from it. Watch the full 4MR Ranch blind test video.

Under a moon the two are hard to tell apart; in real darkness the Gen 3 is clearly cleaner and sees more.

Where does Gen 3 still win?

We sell Gen 2+, and we are not going to pretend this test was a clean sweep. Based on what 4MR Ranch showed:

  • Very low light. At full gain with no moon and no illuminator, and in the dark room, the Gen 3 tube showed more detail and less noise. That is the 13 percent SNR edge doing its job.
  • Reading fine detail in the dark. The text chart test went to Gen 3 by one or two rows.
  • Headroom. If your nights are mostly overcast, deep woods, no moon and no sky glow, a higher FOM tube gives you more to work with.

Where it did not win: under a full moon the tester preferred the Gen 2+ image, and with the IR illuminator on both units were very clear. His closing line sums up the whole test:

"If you were handed either of these pairs, you'd be incredibly happy and impressed." (Kyle, 4MR Ranch, 17:56)

He added that only a direct side by side comparison gives you even a small hint of which one is better, and that the other people he let look through both units struggled too.

What does the price gap look like?

This is where the test matters for your wallet. In the video, Kyle notes that this housing is typically sold with Gen 2+ tubes in the 1600 to 1800 FOM range for about $4,500, and that the Gen 3 route can cost double or triple that (4:02). For reference, a Gen 3 AN/PVS-31A binocular was listed at $13,699.00 by Procyon Industries when we checked on 4 November 2026 (on back order).

Our own PVS-31 PRO binocular starts at $3,599.95 direct for the 1400 grade, and the 1800 grade, one step above the 1619 FOM tube in this test, is $4,949.95. That puts a dual tube Gen 2+ setup in the same bracket as the unit in the video, and roughly a third of what the Gen 3 route asks.

So the honest summary is: the Gen 3 tube was close in this test, better in the darkest scenes, and costs far more. A high grade Gen 2+ tube gets you most of the way there. Whether the last stretch is worth thousands of dollars more depends on how dark your nights really are. If you are still deciding between generations in general, our Gen 2 vs Gen 3 guide covers the wider picture.

Who should buy which?

If you... Our take
Mostly go out with some moon, sky glow or an IR illuminator A high grade Gen 2+ tube. This test showed it trading blows with Gen 3 in those conditions.
Want both eyes and depth perception A Gen 2+ binocular in the 1600 FOM range, the same class as the 0438 unit in the test.
Spend most nights in deep woods with no moon and no illuminator Buy as much FOM as you can, and consider Gen 3 if you can stretch to it. That is where it pulled ahead here.
Use night vision a few times a month Gen 2+. As Kyle put it, for occasional use, spending double or triple is hard to justify.

Which Night Operators grade is closest to the tube in the test?

Both of our analog lines are real night vision: Gen 2+ autogated image intensifier tubes with white phosphor, sold direct by FOM grade, with a QC sheet for your own tube in the box (here is how to read one). The Gen 2+ tube in the test measured 1619 FOM, which sits in our 1600 grade. The PVS-14 comes in two housings at that grade. On the PVS-31 PRO the 1600 grade is sold out right now, so the nearest grades on sale are the 1400 and the 1800.

A helmet and the Night Operators PVS-14 night vision monocular, lit low on a black background

PVS-14 Standard

Gen 2+ monocular in the classic PVS-14 housing, 40 degree view.

Grade nearest the 1619 test tube
1600 grade (1600 to 1750 FOM)
$2,299.95
Starting price
$1,849.95 (1400 grade)

In the box

  • G24 mountG24 mount
  • J-armJ-arm
  • QC sheetQC sheet
  • Sacrificial lensSacrificial lens
  • EyecupEyecup
  • Soft case and hard case
See the PVS-14 Standard
Night Operators PVS-14 PRO Gen 2+ night vision monocular, compact housing, three quarter front view

PVS-14 PRO

Same tube in our compact PRO housing: 50 degree view, shuts off when flipped up.

Grade nearest the 1619 test tube
1600 grade (1600 to 1750 FOM)
$2,334.95
Starting price
$1,884.95 (1400 grade)

In the box

  • G24 mountG24 mount
  • J-armJ-arm
  • QC sheetQC sheet
  • Sacrificial lensSacrificial lens
  • EyecupEyecup
  • Soft case and hard case
See the PVS-14 PRO
Night Operators PVS-31 PRO dual tube Gen 2+ white phosphor night vision binocular, front angle view

PVS-31 PRO

Dual tube binocular, the same kind of housing as the test. 50 degree view per tube.

Grade nearest the 1619 test tube
1800 grade (1800 to 1950 FOM)
$4,949.95
Starting price
$3,599.95 (1400 grade)

In the box

  • G24 mountG24 mount
  • AA x4 battery packAA x4 battery pack
  • QC sheet per tubeQC sheet per tube
  • Hard case
See the PVS-31 PRO

The test used binocular housings, so the closest match by tube grade is the PVS-31 PRO at the 1800 grade, $4,949.95, or the 1400 grade at $3,599.95. The 1800 grade is the highest PVS-31 PRO grade on sale right now. Our units come with our own standard optics, not the upgraded optics fitted to the two test units. If one tube is enough, the PVS-14 at the 1600 grade is $2,299.95 in the Standard housing or $2,334.95 in the PRO housing. Not sure which grade fits your nights? Our guide to choosing a FOM tier walks through it.

Prices as of November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is Gen 2+ night vision good enough?

For most people, yes. In 4MR Ranch's blind test a 1619 FOM Gen 2+ tube and a 2059 FOM Gen 3 tube were hard to tell apart under moonlight, and the tester said you would be happy with either. Gen 3 pulled ahead only in very dark scenes.

Is Gen 2+ or Gen 3 better for hunting?

Gen 3 has more headroom on moonless nights, but in this test a high grade Gen 2+ tube picked out bedded deer at about 85 yards and a power line at 100 yards under a full moon. If most of your nights have some moon or sky glow, a high grade Gen 2+ tube covers the job at a fraction of the price.

What FOM do I need?

A tube around 1600 FOM is where Gen 2+ starts to trade blows with entry Gen 3, which is what this test showed with a 1619 tube. Lower grades still work well under moonlight; higher grades buy you more in the darkest scenes.

Is FOM the only thing that matters?

No. FOM is resolution times signal to noise ratio, so it hides which half is doing the work, and it says nothing about halo, phosphor colour, optics or the housing. In this test the lower FOM tube looked sharper to the tester under the full moon, while the higher FOM tube won in the dark.

Did the tester know which tube was which?

No. 4MR Ranch asked the housing maker not to reveal which serial held which tube until after the video went live, and posted the answer in a pinned comment.

How much more FOM did the Gen 3 tube have?

About 27 percent on paper: 2059 against 1619. Its signal to noise ratio was about 13 percent higher (28.6 against 25.3) and its resolution about 12.5 percent higher (72 against 64 lp/mm).

Credit. The test, the footage and the tube data in this article are by 4MR Ranch, from the video Gen 2 vs Gen 3 Night Vision; Can You Tell The Difference? (Blind Test) (11 April 2026), embedded above with a link back. The tube results come from the channel's pinned comment on that video. 4MR Ranch is not affiliated with Night Operators and did not test our units: both test units were the tester's own, with upgraded optics. The summary and opinions here are ours.

If this test convinced you that a high grade Gen 2+ tube is enough for your nights, the closest match by tube grade to the unit Kyle preferred under the full moon is our binocular at the 1800 grade, sold direct with no dealer layer in between. Every PVS-14 and PVS-31 PRO comes with an L4 G24-pattern helmet mount and a QC sheet for your own tube in the box.

See the PVS-31 PRO

Zurück zum Blog